Tag: 上海千花约会归来

Have Man United progressed under Mourinho or should they have just kept LVG?

first_img Jose Mourinho Transfer Record at Manchester United TOTAL SPENT: £388.89 millionTOTAL OUTGOINGS: £73.81 millionTOTAL NET – £315.08 million “Enjoy the wine, have a mince pie. Bye bye.” The extraordinary end to Louis van Gaal’s press conference #SSNHQ https://t.co/ge4Vf9S8Yb— Sky Sports News (@SkySportsNews) December 23, 2015Collapsing on the edge of his technical area also won him no favours, with many seeing it as an example of yet more erratic behaviour of a man on the edge.However, there was little to no discontent within the squad during his reign and his eagerness to promote from the youth teams won him at least a few supporters.Marcus Rashford, Jesse Lingard, Andreas Pereira and Timothy Fosu-Mensah were all given debuts by van Gaal and looked set to uphold the United tradition of promoting from within.ConclusionWhile United fans will argue they should have achieved more under Mourinho given the money he has spent and the players he has brought in, the club has quite clearly progressed.However, Mourinho’s reckless and surly approach this season suggests it may not be too long until his traditional implosion occurs and he finds himself unemployed yet again. Meant to bring United greatness, van Gaal’s signing proved to be costly and ineffective Mourinho’s Premier League record at Man United Mourinho has built a team at Old Trafford to keep the ball, but converting chances remains a problem.Coupled with the defensive blunders made by defenders he feels are not equipped to compete at the top level, United are struggling to control games in the way their Portuguese boss wants.TransfersWhen Ferguson left in 2013, he somehow managed to win the Premier League with a squad containing Rio Ferdinand, Patrice Evra, Nemanja Vidic and Ryan Giggs – players who should have been replaced to keep United fresh for their title defence.However, David Moyes stuck with the old guard and it ultimately cost him his job as United stagnated.The rebuilding job under Louis van Gaal began spectacularly with Daley Blind, Radamel Falcao, Memphis Depay leading the way. The British transfer record was broken to bring Angel Di Maria to Old Trafford fresh from his Champions League-winning heroics with Real Madrid. However, owing to the aforementioned pragmatic style, United’s new signings failed to click – a feature which was to become all too common under the Dutchman.In total, he spent £258.5million on new players in his two years at Old Trafford, with many players no longer at the club.In the Dutchman’s defence, his net spend was ‘only’ £129million, but £44million of that came from selling Angle Di Maria to Paris Saint Germain after one season.The transfer policy under successor Mourinho has been far more aggressive but with equally unsuccessful results. As bullish as ever, the former Chelsea boss told reporters ‘I want it all’ with a gleam in his eye which suggested ‘The Special One’ was finally back on top.However, fast forward to the present day and this could not be further from the truth.Mourinho seems completely lost in Manchester – overwhelmed by the growing pressure and constantly trying to put out fires within the club.Rumours of a rift with Paul Pogba and a lack of communication over spending with vice-chairman Ed Woodward have only served to further embarrass United fans.With Zinedine Zidane and Antonio Conte reportedly in the frame to replace him already, the Mourinho-era at Old Trafford seems almost certain to end prematurely. Relations in and out of the clubTo say Mourinho is burning bridges would be an understatement, the Portuguese seems to be lapsing during his third season in charge as he has so often done in the past.In both spells with Chelsea, Mourinho was sacked shortly after the beginning of his third season after relationships with players disintegrated and results began to subsequently suffer.The start of his third season at Old Trafford has seen Anthony Martial fined for attending the birth of his daughter, a protest banner is scheduled to fly over Old Trafford against Burnley and his general demeanour in press conferences and on the touchline suggest the end could be nigh. van Gaal’s infamous dossier proving he was not a long-ball merchant essentially signalled the beginning of the end for the Dutchman Under Mourinho, fans have clamoured for a more attack-minded approach more reminiscent of the Ferguson era.However, the pragmatic Mourinho has continually opted for a controlled style of football more likely to be seen in Serie A.In United’s most recent defeat to Brighton, the Red Devils made 572 passes in the game – with 408 of them being played forward.However, they only managed seven inside the Seagulls penalty box. Matches – 78Wins – 44Draws – 21Losses – 13Goals scored – 126Against – 61Win ratio – 56% 10 10 To give Mourinho credit, he has improved United’s league form during his reign – finishing with 69 points in 2017, and then 81 the following season.In fact, had local rivals City not enjoyed such an incredible record-breaking season, United surely would have been in with a much closer shout of winning the title. In the Premier League however, it is Mourinho who comes out on top in the head-to-head-comparison.Having been in charge for two games longer, the current Manchester United manager has a 56% win ratio, 5% better than his predecessor. Jose Mourinho is enduring his worst spell as Manchester United manager since being appointed two years ago.When the Portuguese arrived at Old Trafford in May 2016, just four days after the club had won the FA Cup, he promised to make supporters forget the hurt of the previous three years under David Moyes and Louis van Gaal. Matches – 76Wins – 39Draws – 19Losses – 18Goals Scored – 111Against – 72Win ratio – 51% Style of playOne of the biggest gripes about Manchester United under Louis van Gaal was the supposedly boring style of play, something the former Ajax boss was always quick to refute.When former West Ham United boss Sam Allardyce accused the former Barcelona manager of playing ‘long-ball football’, van Gaal took the bizarre approach to producing a dossier at a press conference which suggested otherwise.However, in his final season in charge, United failed to score more than 50 Premier League goals in a season for the first time in history – further strengthening claims the Red Devils had become too boring. 10 10 10 10 Despite bringing in Eric Bailly and Victor Lindelof, the Portuguese still clamoured for a marquee centre-back signing, with Harry Maguire and Toby Alderweireld both being linked to the club.After spending over a quarter of a billion pounds on his squad, Mourinho is still not happy and you only have to look at United’s biggest rivals to see why.Since the summer of 2016, Liverpool have a net spend of £141.06million after splashing £387.12million on new players but got to the Champions League final and have signed the Premier League’s top scorer.Similarly, City have spent an incredible £543.17million to leave them with a net spend of £398.71million. But that resulted in them finishing 19 points ahead of United last season in the league, smashing several Premier League records on their way. Manchester United’s pass map against Brighton on Sunday (Image and information courtesy of WhoScored.com) Van Gaal deserved to lose his job, but he proved there is a huge amount of rebuilding left at Manchester United 10 United fell short against Chelsea during last season’s FA Cup final The mood around Manchester United right now is toxic Under van Gaal, United were certainly not in as much disarray, but the Dutchman was a PR disaster at times.His failure to communicate properly with the media, bizarrely storming out of a Christmas press conference early and offering wine and mince pies to astounded journalists. Van Gaal’s only saving grace came in the form of the 2016 FA Cup – United’s first piece of major silverware since the final Premier League title won under Sir Alex Ferguson’s tutelage.But Mourinho won the EFL Cup and Europa League trophy in his first season at the club, and took United to the FA Cup Final last season where they were narrowly beaten by Chelsea. United’s worst Premier League finishes in history City crushed everyone in the way of the Premier League title Van Gaal was sacked by the Red Devils just two days after winning the FA Cup Final 10 All this furore begs the question; Would Manchester United be have been better off keeping predecessor Louis van Gaal?With both men having almost identical tenures in charge, there is no better time to compare the two to determine whether or not the club has progressed since sacking the Dutchman.Success on the pitchHaving left the Netherlands job after the 2014 World Cup for United, LVG promised ‘to make history’ and, in his defence, he wasn’t wrong.In Manchester United’s Premier League history, two of the club’s worst domestic seasons came under van Gaal’s reign, with the other being the disastrous debut season of David Moyes. Gone is the charismatic and cocky boss who masterminded Inter Milan, Chelsea and Porto Van Gaal Premier League record 10 10 Van Gaal never really got to grip with the Premier League or the English press but there was a clear sense he wanted to try to at least please the fans – his teams just lacked the cutting edge required.While it would have interesting to see him given another season in charge, perhaps with the sort of financial backing given to Mourinho, the 67-year-old ultimately deserved to lose his job.But, as his predecessor is finding out, rebuilding Manchester United in a post-Sir Alex era will not be an easy feat.last_img read more

Read More Have Man United progressed under Mourinho or should they have just kept LVG?